Reviews and Letters of Recommendation

ProAudio Reviews

See our latest reviews from audioMUSINGS and Secrets of Home Theater & High Fidelity, March 1999

Quotes about from audioMUSINGS - August 1998.

"These speakers [Symphony's] reminded me of an excellent-sounding tube amp - sweet, extended, and grainless."

FRANCISCO DURAN

"When I switched basck to my Proacs, they sounded like little fighting roosters compared to the big, smooth Symphonies."

FRANCISCO DURAN

"True to their design principles, the Symphony's produced images so real that you could reach out and touch them, just like a good mini-monitor."

VICTOR CHAVIRA

"They create subsonic waves of energy that are felt in the balls of your feet and the pit of your stomach."

VICTOR CHAVIRA

"I heard so much detail, and it was so musical, that I knew I was hearing a true high end speaker system."

ROGER McNICHOLS

"The NotePerfect Symphony speakers proved to be accurate and powerful with music of all types."

ROGER McNICHOLS

"These speakers are the antithesis of forward or bright. What's there is smooth and relaxed, with no grain or glare."

DAVE CLARK

For the full review, email audioMUSINGS at audiomusings@earthlink.net

1999 Secrets of Home Theater & High Fidelity

Product Review - Note Perfect Symphony

Floorstanding Speakers - March, 1999
J.E. Johnson, Jr.

I've always been highly impressed with Australian hi-fi products, having auditioned and purchased numerous components from Down Under through the years. After auditioning the Note Perfect Symphonies, I knew that I would continue in that tradition.

The Symphonies are one of an entire line of speakers manufactured by Note Perfect. Although the Symphonies are beautifully crafted with an elegant enclosure, I was much more interested in a unique characteristic of these speakers, namely that the midrange driver has only an inductor in its signal path rather than the usual resistor, inductor, and capacitor. In other words, the midrange driver is wired directly to the amplifier with just the inductor (other than the speaker cable itself) in the circuit. This is accomplished by using a small internal sealed enclosure for the midrange driver that prevents it from having high excursion when low frequencies pass through its voice coil. The upper end rolls off via the inductor. The woofer and tweeter have crossovers, but it is the midrange signal that our ears are most sensitive to, and so, this is where the clever effects of a (nearly) crossoverless design are manifested.

The rear of the enclosure has a metal dome tweeter with a 6 step control. This allows a "presence" or "ambience" adjustment of the high frequencies, and it lightens the soundstage, which is especially useful in small listening rooms. The speaker binding posts are complex, allowing for tri-wiring, bi-amping, and also, if you are really cranking the system, there is a binding post that inserts a capacitor (gasp!) into the midrange driver circuit, and which will prevent any unauthorized excursion of the midrange driver due to high volume. The speakers are 4 Ohms nominal, which means you need an amplifier with a good power supply, but at $7,500/pair for these things, I would think that any consumer in his/her right mind would be pairing them with a terrific amplifier anyway.

We listened to the Symphonies using solid state equipment and CDs. I have to say right off the bat that they sounded like they were being driven by tube amplifiers, with the most lucious midrange I could possibly imagine. I used the rear tweeter adjustment to get a huge soundstage even though the room was relatively small. The silk dome tweeter kept the upper end smooth, and the bass was nice and tight, but oh that midrange. I'm sure that the felt pad around the tweeter and midrange driver, along with the tapered enclosure, made a difference in the mid and high driver interaction, but the lack of a capacitor in the midrange circuit has to be the most important contribution to this sound (capacitors result in smearing).

When it comes right down to the basics, just think about this for a moment. Manufacturers spend months, years, and a lot of money getting the source, the preamplifier, and power amplifier, as well as highly engineered cables, to handle the music signal very carefully with minimum degradation. They make a point of saying that there are no capacitors in this or that circuit, and then what do we do? We put capacitors, resistors, and inductors right in the path just before the signal gets to the speakers! We must . . . must . . . spend more effort in developing speakers with no crossover components in the path. The Symphonies have made headway in this, but a music system with no capacitors or inductors used as crossovers before the power amplifier or after it would be achievable with a digital crossover. Using the digital signal from a CD player, DVD player, or from analog sources converted to digital (A/D), the crossover separates the audio signal into two or three (or more) spectrum parts based on user input. For example, 20 Hz - 250 Hz, 251 Hz - 3500 Hz, and 3501 Hz - 20 kHz could be selected and sent to three power amplifiers for tri-amping a three-way speaker. Slope could be chosen for the specific drivers and enclosure. There would be no phase shift. It would be nice to have it done in 32 bit with 4 MHz clock speed to allow a flat response all the way to 100 kHz.

Of course, it is not as simple as just removing the crossover and building a small sealed enclosure for the midrange driver to make a great speaker. The sound of the Symphonies is a result of total engineering design, not just midrange. Although our ears are most sensitive in the midrange, we can hear the bass and highs too. If they are not right, a clean midrange is useless. The Symphonies have everything just right, and that is something unusual.

Now, I am not going to waste time explaining how 1:24 into track 6 of such and such a CD, the french horns had a lot of "air". We don't do that kind of thing at Secrets. Being a fan of popular singing, I thought that the Symphonies would make a big difference with music sung by the likes of Natalie Cole, which they did. But, what surprised me was how much difference they made with instrument solos such as saxophones and trumpets, particularly when the microphones were close to the horns. The old platitude about being "in the room" doesn't give justice to the sound of these speakers. The horns were in my lap. With so much midrange, I worried that it might come out nasal with some music, but it didn't. Again, this is a careful blending of the midrange driver output with the other two drivers in these speakers. The Symphonies can be ordered with a built-in 150 watt amplifier for the woofer (one in each enclosure), which allows your own amplifier just to concentrate on the midrange and tweeter. This pushes the price to $9,000 per pair.

I'm going to keep this review short and sweet. The Note Perfect Symphonies are not available in many stores in the USA, but I think that they will start showing up here and there, and maybe everywhere, soon. If you come across an audio shop that is smart enough to be carrying them in the future, please give yourself the pleasure of auditioning them.

John E. Johnson, Jr.

© Copyright 1999 Secrets of Home Theater & High Fidelity
Link to original article source
http://www.sdinfo.com/volume_6_1/noteperfectsymphonyspeakers.html

 
ProAudio Review   HOW TO CHOOSE THE RIGHT MONITORS

Hello. My name is Sakis Anastopoulos, owner of Digisound mastering, based in Melbourne, Australia.

Over the past 6 months I had a good chance to test and evaluate many monitors that were designed for mastering applications. These monitors were from different manufacturers and their price range from AU$4000-$50,000.
During the evaluation period of 6 months I was able to test these monitors under extreme processing conditions at various BIT depths and sampling rates and under critical listening sessions. To my surprise many of the so-called "reference" monitors they were everything else but a 'reference' - may were in fact quite poor. Also to my surprise quite costly monitors fell into this category!

I am not a millionaire and therefore I had to choose very carefully the monitor that will fit within my budget and that will enable me to do my job with precision.

When mastering the engineer must be able to:

1- Evaluate the master with precision.
2- Make the right decisions when processing.
If the monitoring setup is not accurate these decisions are impossible to make, as you can understand. If the monitors are not telling you the truth while evaluating a project then you are going to end up making the wrong decisions and touching the wrong buttons in your processing equipment.
If you end up with a master that has been processed incorrectly then it will give you different results when played back in different systems. We cannot afford to take such risks and therefore cannot have an inferior monitoring setup at the mastering stage.

Well, most of the reference monitors that I tested were lacking in accuracy at one stage or another. Some had very good frequency response but their soundstage was not detailed, some had good soundstage but many dips in various frequency ranges. Mostly, though, the midrange was very colored.

Choosing a mastering monitor is not an easy task. There are far too many things that the monitor has to be tested for and this takes time and knowledge and most of all well trained ears.

So, after all these tests and time spent choosing the right one for you how do you know that you have end up with the right monitor? Which is the best out of all?

THE BEST MONITOR IS THE ONE THAT WILL HELP YOU TO MAKE ALL YOUR DECISIONS ON.

This monitor will be with you because you are comfortable evaluating, processing and mastering with it. This monitor will give you the confidence that you need at the critical mastering stage, that your masters are going to translate equally well when played back through different monitoring systems.

Can your mastering monitors do all this? Is it hard to find such monitors?
Well, read on as the following one was the ultimate for me and is my right hand when mastering.

THE BRAND

I came across the NotePerfect homepage (www.noteperfect.com.au) about 8 weeks ago, and since I was in the market for new monitors I checked out all their models that I thought were suitable for my application.

Dropping a simple e-mail request for information to Mike Kontor made the first steps towards my testing his products.

THE GUY

Mike Kontor is a very down to earth and knowledgeable guy. He stands beside his products and he's there to help you choose the right one. He is not the salesman that you'll find in your Pro-audio store insisting that this is the right monitor for you because the rest of the recording or mastering studios have all got it as their reference monitor.

Mike was kind enough to let me test 3 of his monitors and I am grateful for this kindness.

THE "ALPHA"

This is a great nearfield monitor very well priced and suitable for any tracking and mixing applications. I was amazed by it's performance and I wouldn't hesitate to recommend it to anyone who's looking for a monitor for these applications. It has incredible bass for its size and outperforms well known PRO AUDIO monitors costing mnay thousands of dollars.

THE "VIRTUOSO"

Now, this is a great midfield monitor suitable for mastering applications. Its bass is fast and accurate, with a detailed soundstage and killer mids and highs. Very well priced and it's design will help you install it in a room where space is an issue. It's exactly the same as the model below but without the same bass extension. I love it and I challenge anyone who's in the market for mastering monitors to find anything in this price range. Even monitors double its price won't give you the performance of the Virtuoso. The treble output is adjustable, a real boon.

THE "SYMPHONY"

WOW. I don't know where to start and where to end with this one. I can easily write a book full of compliments about it. Whatever values you are looking in a mastering monitor you are going to find them in this one. If you think that your monitors are accurate enough having a listen to the Symphonies will make them sound colored. This is the ultimate in reference monitoring with fast and accurate bass response, killer mids and highs like the Virtuoso model and unbeatable soundstage. There's this monitor and then the rest. It stands on a league of it's own and helps me make my decisions fast. I COULD NOT IMAGINE MYSELF MASTERING WITHOUT IT.

THE BOTTOM LINE

Mastering is the art where the mastering engineer has to face the challenge of bridging the gap between the performer and the listener. This is not an easy task and therefore in order to let our ears make all the right decisions, here at Digisound Mastering we choose to use the Note Perfect Symphony.

Sakis Anastopoulos
Digisound Mastering
KJ West One






Dear Mike,

Thanks for your fax.

The absence of brochures isn't a problem [these had not arrived yet in England at time of this writing - M. Kontor ]; I think if a product is good enough then it doesn't need literature - it stands up in its own right.

We are getting on really well with the speakers. We knew they were good when we first heard them [at the London Ramada Hi-Fi Show] (that's why we took them on!) But it's only just dawning on us just how good they are.

It's rare for us to get a product which all the staff like, but your speakers have attained this, and Phil is thinking of getting a set for himself.

They are certainly one of the best, if not the best, brands we have and we will probably be getting rid of the Wilson Witts! (Please don't quote me on this!)

Anyhow, we've already sold our Virtuosos, so would be grateful if you would send a Proforma for another set in piano finish.

Incidentally, we only noticed after some time that the colour of our Virtuosos was a very sublte green! Was this intentional [yes ] or accidental?! If it was intentinal, we'll have another set the same.

Best regards,
Peter Sanhen


Note from :
The Virtuoso's that KJ WEST ONE sold in one afternoon's auditioning were bought by a dyed in the wool audiophile who normally takes months to make a decision about a new piece of gear.  The green finish is piano black with a green metallic sheen deep within the black, noticable only in certain lights.  It's an "optional extra", at a small increase in price.

Daa Woong Inc.
Seoul
Korea

Mr. M. Kontor
Leading Edge Audio
Melbourne
Australia

18/7/96

Dear Mr. Kontor,

Thank you for your fax. I receive the replacement grilles OK.

Sorry not to write sooner, but I have been overseas on business. You asked me how business is going here with the NotePerfect distribution. We have appointed no new dealers since last year. This is because the economy here is very bad. This year 5 high end shops close down already.

Everyone here who has heard the NotePerfect speakers agree that they outperform all other high end brands like Wilson, ProAc, etc. We will continue with promotion and hope to have and order for you soon.

Kind regards,


I. Jung
Director
Note: The names and addresses of the writers of the following letters are withheld in the interests of security. The letters were unsolicited and are reprinted verbatim. Highlighting and italics are my own - M. Kontor, NotePerfect Loudspeakers.
Mike Kontor
Leading Edge Audio
447 North Road
Ormond

4/8/95

Dear Mike,

I'd just like to let you know how excited I am with my new speakers, the Note Perfect "Symphony".

I have had quite a few speakers over the years, including Apogees, Acarian Alons and Whatmough Monitors, but none have given me as much musical enjoyment as the Note Perfects.

As in the usual quest for the perfect sound I have been changing equipment almost yearly. A recent change to 160 watt valve monoblock amplifiers (from a Classe DR9) improved my soundsystem, but the major improvement has come from buying the Note Perfect "Symphony" speakers. They are beautifully transparent, the soundstage and the dynamics are superb, the tonal qualities rich and seamless. I am hearing musical details and instruments that I never knew were in the recordings. As a friend remarked, the musicians seemed to be in the room with us.

My present system includes an Aura turntable with SME 5 and a Benz-Micro MC3 Ruby cartridge, 160watt De Silva valve mono amps, a Meridian CD200 payer with Analog Research DAC plus Classe DR6 preamp.

With the Note Perfect "Symphony" speakers as my latest and finest addition I feel that my quest for musical bliss is over. The music that blooms so effortlessly from these speakers is just wonderful.

All the best for the year,
Yours sincerely,

Simon K.
Audio Synthesis
Manchester
UK

Attn. David Heaton

11/7/95

Dear David ,

The DAX and PASSION V that I puchased from you are performing very well in conjunction with a WADIA WT3200 Transport, TUBEWORKS JC8 valve power amps and most recently a pair of NOTE PERFECT "Symphony" loudspeakers.

I would like to draw your attention to these speakers as they are most impressive. They are manufactured here in Australia and beat everything else I have owned or auditioned, including Martin Logan CLS and Quests, Apogee Duetta Sig. And Diva, Acararian Alon IV, Aerial 10T, Avalon Ascent, etc.

The manufacture is looking for export distribution and intends to show this product in his own room at the UK HiFi Show in September. I have taken the liberty of giving him your name and contact details in case you might be interested in evaluating this product for distribution.

I have no commercial interest in this matter but would like to see the product succeed as I think it has reference class sound. Please give it a listen, I am sure you will be impressed.

The manufacturer is Mike Kontor of Leading Edge Audio and I expect he will contact you in due course.

Best regards,


(name withheld for security reasons)

[Mr. Heaton was most impressed when he heard the speakers at the show, in fact, he wanted to buy the pair of Symphony's that were there, but of course KJ WEST ONE took the line on.]
Mike Kontor
Leading Edge Audio
Ormond

26/8/95

Mike,

It's time I set pen to paper to tell you how pleased and happy I am with the NotePerfect "Symphony" speakers. Without doubt, these are the best speakers I have heard. Previous speakers I have owned (Magneplanar, Duntech) do not compare - nor do various brands (Castle, Mirage, Monitor Audio, ProAc, Quad) auditioned at the recent Melbourne HiFi Show. None compare with the NotePerfects - either in musical performance or value for money.

The NotePerfect's clarity and warmth have caused my musical enjoyment to reach new heights. Electronics and transducers cannot duplicate a live performance, but with the contribution of the Note Perfects my system comes significantly closer to the feeling of "being there".

Even poorly recorded CD's sound better, and well recorded music sounds magnificent. With the Note Perfects installed, positioned and run in, I have played CD after CD, and always with the same result - increased musical enjoyment.

Please accept my thanks for introducing me to the Note Perfect "Symphony" speakers,

Wishing you every success,

Daryl W.

Dear Mike,

re: NotePerfect "CONCERT" speakers

I just want to thank you for a most enjoyable demonstration last Friday, in your store, of the NotePerfect "Concert'" speakers.

The manner in which they provided musical enjoyment in the playing of Grieg's piano concerto, the Adagio from the Delos sampler, and the Louis Armstrong tracks, was just breathtaking and I just can't wait to receive my pair.

As agreed I have much pleasure in enclosing a cheque for the change over from my Duntech's. Looking forward to you call regarding freight arrangements.

Yours sincerely,


David M.

WHY WE BOUGHT NOTE PERFECT SYMPHONY SPEAKERS

It really was an easy decision to buy the NotePerfect speakers.

We had listened to them at Leading Edge Audio and were so impressed that we requested an extended home evaluation. Needless to say, that's where they stayed.

We had been hankering for an upgrade in speakers for some time and had listened all over Melbourne for something we may have liked. Speakers brought home for evaluation included Mirage and Martin Logan, but both were found wanting.

What we were looking for was a speaker that was as musical as the Magneplanar MGIIc's we were then using but which were also considerably better. The only areas of criticism with the Maggies were the limited and flabby bass, imprecise imaging, lack of high frequency extension and slight lacking in dynamics.

The NotePerfect's were an answer to our prayers.

As musical as the Maggies and better in every respect.

A huge three dimensional sound stage, imaging that was preicse, incredibly detailed, and extended bass response that deemed an sub-woofer unnecessary, a tight and fast bass response, and open and extended top end. Very transparent.

We have still not heard any speaker that could equal the Symphony's. Not that we are looking too hard.

Cate & Paul
Melbourne

[Cate & Paul re-iterated the last paragraph of their letter after a recent around the world trip during which they listened to severtal mega-buck speakers, including the big Genesis! Praise indeed! - Mike Kontor]

Mike Kontor
Leading Edge Audio
Ormond

30/8/95

Dear Mike,

I just want to thank you for recommending the NotePerfect Concerts. As you know, I previously owned STAX electrostatics which were notoriously hard to drive. Although with thousands of dollars spent on amplification (VTL), we eventually got them sounding exceptionally sweet but still bass-less.

The Concerts are a whole new ballgame. They have renewed my interest in music. I have them connected to a high end surround sound amplfier. I use them for playing records, CD's and listening to videos. They were easy to set up and sounded rich and sweet from the moment they were connected. I followed the set up recommendations, not fitting the spikes until I had found the best listening area. I was reasonably happy with the sound, but the spikes gave a dramatic improvement. The sound stage improved, the bass went even deeper and the top end extended. They now fool me into thinking I have electronics with superb bass. I love these speakers. The more I listen to them, the more I enjoy them. I have now set up a surround sound system and am enjoying it thoroughly. I was dubious at first, thinking it a gimmick. I was very wrong. The Concerts involve you in the soundtrack, adding new dimensions to movies and making television worth watching.

I have never been interested in aesthetics of speakers, preferring performance, but the finish on the NotePerfects is like having a grand piano in my living room. Thanks once again for a superb product. I have no hesitation in recommending them to anyone.

Regards,

Allan K.
Born Again Music Lover
Dear Mike,

I didn't have much of a chance to speak to you at the recent Melbourne Hi-Fi Show, but I wanted to tell you that after doing th rounds at the show, there was only one speaker I like better than my recently acquired NotePerfect "Concerts", and that was the NotePerfect "Virtuosos"! And that should be so, as these are more expensive than the Concerts. Despite all the expensive equipment at the show, I found all the other well known speakers - ProAc, Duntech, Martin-Logan, etc. - to be very coloured and unnatural sounding, compared to the NotePerfects. To me this was very re-assuring, the NotePerfects being Australian made and not nearly as expensive as many of the imports. Nice to see we can be just as good and then some!

I wanted to tell you this, because you will remember my apprehension when I bought the speakers, as they were relatively new and unknown then, and my faith at that time was in the English made speakers. Now that the NotePerfect's reputation is firmly established, I'm glad to have been one of the first to trust his ears and take the plunge.

Kindest regards,
D.W.
15/8/95
Newsgroups: IDEA.EMUEnsoniqPARIS

As I mentioned last week, I ordered a pair of Note Perfect Alpha Pro monitors (www.noteperfect.com.au)

A couple of people said they'd be interested to hear what I thought of them so here are my initial impressions.

First off, I have been using Event 20/20 bas powered monitors for the last few years. One problem I always had was judging the low end with them. If I got the bass sounding good on the Events, on any other system the track would be _very_ muddy.

One of the first things I noticed with the Note Perfects is how revealing they are. I put in a CD I am very familiar with and started hearing subtle parts that I had never noticed before. Just to be sure, I listened again on the Events (and my roommates KRKs) and I could barely make out the part I could hear quite clearly on the Alphas Pros

The midrange reproduction on these is something else! Amazing clarity and definition.

I pulled up one of my mixes I have been working on and noticed right away that I could judge the bass level much more accurately. This was confirmed by listening to a quick mix I did for the car and home stereo. The levels were very even and the mix translated very well to different systems. No longer will I have to second guess what my monitors are doing and try to compensate for them. I still need to learn to mix well, but that's another story and I think the Alphas will play a big role in that. :)

ESQ.- I can finally hear subtle adjustments in EQ! Before, I would have to cut/add about +5/-5 db to really hear the slightest change in the midrange but now even small adjustments are very noticeable. I feel like I can more accurately tell when I need to cut something, especially in the midrange on things like guitars, snares etc.

Another thing I noticed about the Alphas is what happens when you turn them up and give them some volume.

On my old monitors, turning them up was very addictive because the sound would get "hyped" The bass response would change.... everything would change.... it wasn't the same mix anymore but it sounded good. ;) (Fletcher/Munson curve etc)

The Alphas don't do this. When I turn them up, they get louder but the mix does not change. I do not sense any "hyping" and I think this is a very good thing. I usually get the best results by mixing at very low levels but I thought I would point this out.

I do want to mention what a great guy Mike Kontor of Note Perfect is.

He makes them upon order and it took about 4 days total for him to build them and show up on my door from Australia. (I was thinking it would take much longer and be much more expensive LOL!)

To top it off, he spent about 4 hours one day helping me find a good power amp for them on EBAY. That was very cool as I know don't know squat about power amps and what to look for. I feel he really went out of his way for me on that one. For the record I ended up with a B&K ST202

For the record, The Alpha Pros cost in the $2000 range but the exchange rate for American currency is almost 2-1 to the Australian dollar so for under $1500 (including the amp and shipping) I think I have a very accurate monitoring system.

Well worth checking out.

best,

Craig